How to write comparison, alternatives and pricing pages for AI search
Short answer: A useful decision page helps a buyer choose, even when the right choice is a competitor. Put a clear verdict first, show differences a reader can check, date every price and fact, say who each option suits, and declare that you made the page. Those qualities make the page useful to people and easier for others to reference accurately. They don’t guarantee that ChatGPT, Perplexity or Google’s AI features will cite it, and no one can promise that.
This guide covers the three common decision pages, gives a fully worked fictional example of each, and ends with templates you can copy.
What is a decision page?
A decision page is any page whose job is to help someone choose. There are three common types:
| Type | The question it answers | Typical URL |
|---|---|---|
| X vs Y | “Which is better for me, X or Y?” | /compare/x-vs-y/ |
| Alternatives | “What else could I use instead of X?” | /alternatives/x/ |
| Pricing | “How much does it cost, and what do I get?” | /pricing/ |
They sit late in the research journey. Someone asking “X or Y?” usually already knows the category and has a shortlist.
Do AI answers use decision pages?
Some do, some of the time, and nobody outside the AI companies can say exactly when. OpenAI, Google, Perplexity and the others don’t publish a full description of how their assistants choose which pages to draw on, so treat any claim that a particular page format “gets lifted” as a hypothesis.
What is documented is Google’s entry requirement for its own AI features. Its guidance on AI features and your website says that to be eligible as a supporting link in AI Overviews or AI Mode, “a page must be indexed and eligible to be shown in Google Search with a snippet”, and that “there are no additional technical requirements”. There’s no special format for comparison pages.
So the practical case for a decision page is simpler than any AI theory. If nobody has published a fair, specific, current comparison, people comparing you with a competitor get their answer from whatever else exists: a competitor’s page, an old review or a forum thread. A good page of your own gives them a checkable alternative.
The honesty test
Before you publish, ask: would this page still be useful if a competitor’s customer read it?
If the answer is no, it’s an advert. Google’s guidance on writing high-quality reviews describes what a useful comparison does, and it applies to services as much as products. Among other things, it says to:
- “Explain what sets something apart from its competitors.”
- “Cover comparable things to consider, or explain which might be best for certain uses or circumstances.”
- “Discuss the benefits and drawbacks of something, based on your own original research.”
- “When recommending something as the best overall or the best for a certain purpose, include why you consider it the best, with first-hand supporting evidence.”
Four rules follow:
- Declare your interest. A comparison written by one of the options is fine if it says so near the top. A hidden interest is what destroys trust.
- Say where the other option wins. If a competitor is cheaper, quicker to set up or better for a particular customer, write that down.
- Date every fact. Prices, plan limits and features change. “Checked 12 November 2026” next to a table tells the reader how far to trust it.
- Link to primary sources. Point to each vendor’s own pricing and feature pages, not a third-party summary.
Example 1: an X vs Y page (fictional)
Fictional example. RotaNorth and ShiftLark are invented staff-rota apps. Every price, feature and date below is made up to show the structure. Neither is a real product.
RotaNorth’s own comparison page might look like this.
Title: RotaNorth vs ShiftLark: which rota app suits your team?
Disclosure line: “We make RotaNorth. We’ve tried to be fair to ShiftLark, and we link to its own pages so you can check.”
Verdict: “Choose RotaNorth if you run one or two sites and want holiday requests and payroll export in the same app. Choose ShiftLark if you manage more than ten locations or need a free plan for a small team.”
Comparison table (checked 12 November 2026):
| RotaNorth | ShiftLark | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | £3 per staff member a month, billed monthly, excluding VAT | £2.50 per staff member a month, billed annually, excluding VAT |
| Free plan | No; 14-day trial | Yes, up to 5 staff |
| Minimum contract | Monthly, cancel any time | 12 months on paid plans |
| Holiday requests | Included | Paid add-on |
| Payroll export | Included (CSV) | Included on the top plan only |
| Multi-site management | Up to 5 sites | Unlimited |
| Best for | Single-site cafés, shops and clinics | Chains and franchise groups |
Sections that follow, one per real difference: “Which is cheaper for a team of 12?” (with the arithmetic shown for both, monthly and annual), “Which is easier to set up?”, “Which handles several sites better?” Each heading is a question and the first sentence answers it.
Who should choose ShiftLark: “If you have more than five sites, ShiftLark is the better fit: RotaNorth caps multi-site management at five. If you have five staff or fewer and don’t need holiday requests, ShiftLark’s free plan will cost you nothing.”
Sources: links to ShiftLark’s pricing page and feature list, and RotaNorth’s own.
Owner and review date: “Maintained by [named person]. Next check: February 2027.”
What makes this work: the verdict names a reason for each choice; every cell can be checked on the vendors’ own pages; the page says plainly where the competitor wins.
Example 2: an alternatives page (fictional)
Fictional example. All businesses, prices and dates are invented.
Title: Alternatives to ShiftLark for small teams (2026)
Disclosure line: “We make RotaNorth, which appears on this list. We ranked it on the same criteria as everyone else.”
Criteria, stated before the list: “We compared options on monthly cost for a 12-person team, minimum contract, and whether holiday requests are included. We didn’t include apps built mainly for enterprises with more than 500 staff.”
| Option | Cost for 12 staff, per month (checked 12 November 2026) | Contract | Holiday requests | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ShiftLark (the original) | £30, billed annually | 12 months | Paid add-on | Multi-site groups |
| RotaNorth (ours) | £36, billed monthly | Monthly | Included | Single-site businesses that want everything in one app |
| Teamplan Basic | £0 up to 15 staff | None | Not available | Very small teams on a tight budget |
| Clockwise Rota | £48, billed monthly | Monthly | Included | Teams that also need time clocks |
Under the table, each option gets two or three sentences: what it does well, what it lacks, and a link to its own pricing page.
What makes this work: four real alternatives rather than fifteen padded ones; criteria published first; the author’s own product placed by those criteria and labelled; a cheaper option shown honestly.
Example 3: a pricing page for a service business (fictional)
Fictional example. Harbour Lane Accounts is an invented firm. The prices are illustrative only.
Title: Bookkeeping prices
Opening line: “Monthly bookkeeping starts at £150 a month plus VAT for sole traders. Most limited companies pay between £250 and £450 a month plus VAT. Prices last reviewed 1 November 2026.”
| Package | Price | Billing | Includes | Costs extra |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sole trader | From £150 a month plus VAT | Monthly, 3 months’ notice | Bank reconciliation, quarterly VAT return | Self Assessment return (£250 one-off plus VAT) |
| Limited company | From £250 a month plus VAT | Monthly, 3 months’ notice | Bookkeeping, VAT returns, payroll for up to 5 staff | Year-end accounts (quoted separately) |
| Catch-up bookkeeping | From £400 one-off plus VAT | One-off | Bringing up to 12 months of records up to date | Anything older than 12 months |
What changes the price: number of transactions a month, number of staff on payroll, and whether you use accounting software we support.
How to get an exact quote: “Book a 20-minute call. We’ll confirm a fixed monthly price in writing before you commit.”
What makes this work: a number, a currency and a period next to every price; one-off and recurring charges clearly separated; VAT stated; the factors that change the price spelled out; a review date.
Templates you can copy
Disclosure line
“We make [your product]. This page compares it with [competitor] as fairly as we can. Facts were checked on [date] and we link to [competitor]'s own pages so you can verify them.”
Verdict
“Choose [option A] if you need [specific situation or requirement]. Choose [option B] if you need [specific situation or requirement].”
Selection criteria (alternatives pages)
“We compared options on [criterion 1], [criterion 2] and [criterion 3]. We excluded [type of option] because [reason].”
Feature matrix rows that buyers use: price with currency and billing period; VAT treatment; free plan or trial; minimum contract; what’s included; what costs extra; setup time; who it’s built for; checked date.
Competitor strengths
“[Competitor] is the better choice if [specific situation]. It [concrete advantage, such as a lower price for larger teams].”
Evidence line for any claim of your own
“[Claim], based on [how you know: your own test, a dated customer result, a public source], [date].”
Pricing statement
“[Package] costs [currency][amount] [per month / one-off] [including / excluding VAT]. Includes [list]. Costs extra: [list]. Prices last reviewed [date].”
Maintenance line
“Maintained by [name, role]. Next review: [month year].”
How to keep decision pages from going stale
A comparison with an out-of-date competitor price is a factual error with your name on it. Put the upkeep in writing:
- Name an owner for each decision page: one person who re-checks it.
- Re-check every quarter, and whenever you or a listed competitor changes prices or plans.
- Keep a short log of what you checked, where, and when. A screenshot with a date is enough.
- Update the “checked” date only when you’ve actually re-checked. Moving the date without checking is worse than leaving an old date.
- Retire options that close or change category, rather than leaving them on the list.
What about schema?
You don’t need special markup for decision pages. Google’s AI features guidance says “there’s also no special schema.org structured data that you need to add”. Use the ordinary types that describe the page:
- Comparison or alternatives article: Article, with the author and the dates shown on the page.
- Your own product’s pricing page: Product with an Offer carrying the visible price and currency.
- Every page: BreadcrumbList that matches the visible breadcrumb.
Two of Google’s rules matter most here. From its general structured data guidelines: “Don’t mark up content that is not visible to readers of the page.” And from its review snippet guidelines: if the business being reviewed controls the reviews about itself, its pages using LocalBusiness or Organization markup are “ineligible for star review feature”. Don’t add star ratings to your own comparison or pricing pages to try to get them. The schema in 2026 guide covers what Google still supports.
Mistakes that weaken a decision page
- Unsupported numbers. “Customers save 40%” with no customer, date or method is a claim, not a fact. If you have a real result, write it the way the customer proof guide describes. If you don’t, leave the number out.
- “Best” with no criteria. A ranking that doesn’t explain itself gives the reader no reason to trust it.
- Stale competitor facts. See the maintenance list above.
- Tables that only appear after a click or a script runs. Put the table in the page’s HTML so it’s there for every reader and every crawler.
- No verdict. A page that lists differences but never says who should choose what leaves out the most useful sentence.
Checklist
- Pick the three comparison questions your customers actually ask before choosing.
- Write a verdict for each that names who each option suits.
- Build a comparison table with facts you checked, and date it.
- Declare that you made the page.
- Add a section on who should choose the other option.
- Link to each vendor’s own pricing and feature pages.
- Publish prices with currency, billing period, VAT treatment and what’s included.
- Name an owner and put a quarterly re-check in the calendar.
Start with the comparison your sales team is asked about most. When it’s live, run a free SearchScore audit to check that the page can be crawled, read and understood, then read the findings in order of priority. If you want to see which websites AI answers in your market already draw on, that’s what the AI Visibility Playbook maps.
Sources
Google sources checked 12 November 2026.
- Google Search Central, AI features and your website
- Google Search Central, Write high quality reviews
- Google Search Central, General structured data guidelines
- Google Search Central, Review snippet structured data
Frequently asked questions
Should I publish a comparison page against a competitor?
Yes, if you can be fair and keep it current. Say that you made the page, give a verdict that names who each option suits, put the facts in a table with the date you checked them, and link to the competitor's own pages so a reader can check what you wrote. If you can't commit to re-checking it every quarter, don't publish it.
Is it acceptable to put my own product first on an alternatives page?
Only if you say at the top that you made the page, publish the criteria you ranked on, and apply the same criteria to yourself. A list that ranks its author first with no stated criteria reads as an advert. Google's guidance on reviews asks for the reason something is called the best, with first-hand supporting evidence.
Should pricing be public if every quote is different?
Publish what you can: a from-price, what moves the price up or down, what's included, what costs extra, whether VAT is included, and whether it's a one-off or a subscription. A page that only says "contact us" leaves people, and any tool summarising prices for them, to rely on other sources.
Do I need special schema for comparison pages?
No. Google says there's no special schema.org structured data you need to add for its AI features. Use the ordinary types that match the page, such as Article for a comparison and Product with an Offer on a pricing page for a product, and keep every marked-up value visible on the page.
Will a decision page get my business cited by ChatGPT or Google's AI answers?
Nobody can promise that. No AI company publishes exactly how it chooses sources. A fair, specific, dated page is more useful to the people comparing options and easier for anyone, including other writers, to reference accurately. That's the honest case for building one.