The question
When a page overlaps another and you must decide whether to redirect it or keep it live.
Two of your pages overlap in topic and you are deciding whether to consolidate one into the other via redirect.
Why it matters
Redirecting a page that serves a distinct intent collapses two winning positions into one and loses coverage, while keeping overlapping pages live sustains cannibalisation that splits rankings and confuses engines.
How to decide
IfIf both pages target the same intent and compete for the same queries
ThenYes - redirect the weaker into the stronger to consolidate signals.
IfIf each page serves a genuinely distinct intent or audience
ThenNo - keep both and differentiate them clearly, with a canonical only if needed.
IfIf one page is outdated but the topic still matters
ThenNo - refresh or merge content into the survivor before redirecting.
IfIf the redirect would break a valuable long-tail entry point
ThenNo - preserve the entry point or fold its unique content into the target first.